you're reading...
evidence based medicine, pregnancy

Water birth leads to newborn’s death from Legionella

Water births, delivering a baby so it is born underwater, are controversial medically because while they are promoted as safe and natural by some midwives and lay midwives they are not recommended by the American Academy of Pediatrics and the American Congress of OB/GYN. (Laboring in a tub in an entirely different thing).

The January 2015 issue of Emerging Infectious Diseases is reporting the death of a newborn fromheader_vp3 to Legionella acquired during a water birth attended by a licensed midwife in Texas. The baby was admitted on day 6 of life with sepsis due to Legionella and died after 19 days in the hospital. There were several issues identified by the Texas Department of State Health Services:

  • The tub was not designed or approved for use as medical equipment and so had internal tubing difficult to disinfect
  • The midwife attempted to disinfect the water in the tub with a non–Food and Drug Administration approved product
  • The water was left circulating for an extended period of time prior to use
  • The water was well water

Warm, moist environments are ideal places for Legionella to thrive. Hot tubs are a known source. In this case the Legionella may have been aerosolized from the jets (and so the baby may have inhaled it after being retrieved from the water) or may have aspirated water into the lungs while submerged. Well water is easily contaminated with Legionella, but even tap water is at risk so that is why nebulizers (machines that vaporize medicine so it can be inhaled) need sterile water and why the tubing needs regular cleaning.

Infection with Legionella is not uncommon. According to the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) about 8,000–18,000 people in the United States are hospitalized with the infection. Those who are at higher risk include:

  • Individuals who are 50 years of age or older
  • Smokers
  • People with chronic lung disease
  • Individuals with weakened immune systems (this would include a newborn)

There is very little known about the safety of the water births. There are a few retrospective studies, but not enough data to formulate an opinion either way. There are reports of cord accidents (tearing the umbilical cord at delivery with catastrophic bleeding), infections in the baby, and near drowning and drowning. How common these events are is unknown. Certainly any tub used for delivery that can’t be properly cleaned is a potential hazard as is water that is not properly disinfected.

An intervention that is unstudied can’t be touted as safe or unsafe, if you are honest you say the safety is simply unknown. Some midwives and lay midwives promote water births as natural, which is, in my opinion, ludicrous. Much of the word’s population evolved away from water that body temperature, water is often laden with bacteria that might be just fine on the skin but potentially deadly when inhaled, and human babies haven’t evolved a mechanism to safely breath hold when submerged immediately on delivery. There is a lot of misunderstanding surrounding the physiology of the first breath and Dr. Clay Jones, a pediatrician, does a great job of reviewing what happens with breathing and the lungs on delivery over at Science Based Medicine:

The dive reflex only occurs when the face is submerged in very cold water. Breath holding associated with submersion in cold water is an involuntary process where breathing is centrally inhibited. What waterbirth proponents are confusing the dive reflex with here is drowning.

What does this case report tell us about water births? It reinforces what we already know, that spa tubs are breeding grounds for bacteria and unless they can be properly cleaned and the water kept disinfected there will always be a potential for serious infections for a newborn. The bacteria can be inhaled if a baby gasps in the water, but even after delivery while a baby is laying on her mother’s chest she will be breathing in a bacterial plume aerosolized by the tub’s water jets.

The percentage of babies who will get sick from this is unknown, but the risk should not be dismissed.

 

 

 

Discussion

2 thoughts on “Water birth leads to newborn’s death from Legionella

  1. As a former L&D RN, go to a hospital for your delivery. I worked with midwives within the hospital and we
    never had a problem. So sorry to read about this.

    Posted by bethhavey | December 13, 2014, 2:13 pm
  2. Having designed and supplied portable birth pools from 1987 and installed pools in hospitals since 1988 I probably have a greater knowledge and understanding of the issues relating to their design, engineering and manufacture then any one else.

    I created the largest birth pool hire company in the UK hiring out 75-90 portable pools a month and never had an infection control issue.

    It’s simple.

    These are the rules that need to be followed.

    NO recirculating systems of any sort!

    This means no jets, no bubbles, no heating, no filtering systems of any sort – just a pool of fresh water, and by fresh I mean no more then 12 hours old.

    You’d be amazed how quickly life takes root in a pool of warm water, you can actually feel that after 12 hours a pool of body temperature water feels differently to the way it did originally.

    Fill the pool with a new hosepipe.

    Hosepipes, piping, tubes of any sort and pumps are the No. 1 Risk!

    You don’t know what is going on inside them and you can’t take the risk.

    So, fill your birth pool with a NEW hosepipe once your in established labour and play it safe.

    IF its a pool that has been used before USE a disposable liner to negate risk of cross infection.

    Anything that has been in contact with water before must not be in contact with the water in your birth pool!

    For water birth pools that are installed in hospital its even more straightforward:

    The pool should not have:

    • Overflow drains

    • Water Inlets

    • Hand held showers

    • Systems with flexible hoses or pipes for filling and emptying

    • Integral or secondary plumbing supply or outlet systems

    • Any type of recirculating or pumped water systems such as whirlpool, Jacuzzi, spa, heating, bubbling, filtering etc.

    To ensure that health & safety and infection control standards are met we strongly advise that you do not use a water birth pool that has any of these features.

    Water Birth Pools should be filled from taps plumbed directly into the hospitals water supply as normal baths are and emptied as a normal bath would be.

    Not only do secondary or integral plumbing systems of a proprietary nature present unacceptable risks, they are expensive to purchase, difficult to maintain and unnecessary.

    The benefits of water for labour and birth are clear and understood.

    The world is poised on a threshold in the proliferation of their use following successful models in the United Kingdom and other countries.

    It must be safe!

    For more information on the plumbing of water birth pools please go to http://www.activebirthpools.com

    Posted by keithbrainin | January 2, 2015, 11:49 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Recent Tweets

%d bloggers like this: